• Newsletter
  • Search
  • Contacto
  • Home (next newsletter)
  • Home
  • News # 80 | Jun. 2018
  • News # 81 | Jul. 2018
  • News # 82 | Set. 2018
  • News # 83 | Oct. 2018
  • News # 84 | Nov. 2018
  • News # 85 | Dec. 2018
  • News # 86 | Jan. 2019
  • News # 87 | Feb. 2019
  • News # 88 | Mar. 2019
  • News # 89 | Apr. 2019
  • News # 90 | May. 2019
  • News # 91 | Jun. 2019
  • News # 92 | Jul. 2019
  • News # 93 | sep. 2019
  • Newsletters
    • 2008 – 2009
      • News # 1 | nov. 2008
      • News # 10 | nov/dez. 2009
      • News # 2 | dec. 2008
      • News # 3 | jan/fev. 2009
      • News # 4 | mar. 2009
      • News # 5 | abr. 2009
      • News # 6 | mai/jun. 2009
      • News # 7 | jul. 2009
      • News # 8 | ago/set. 2009
      • News # 9 | out. 2009
    • 2010 – 2011
      • News # 11 | jan/fev. 2010
      • News # 12 | mar. 2010
      • News # 13 | abr. 2010
      • News # 14 | mai. 2010
      • News # 15 | jun/jul. 2010
      • News # 16 | ago/set. 2010
      • News # 17 | out/nov. 2010
      • News # 18 | dez. 2010
      • News # 19 | jan/fev. 2011
      • News # 20 | mar/abr. 2011
      • News # 21 | mai/jun. 2011
      • News # 22 | jul/ago. 2011
      • News # 23 | set/out. 2011
      • News # 24 | nov/dez. 2011
    • 2012 – 2013
      • News # 25 | jan. 2012
      • News # 26 | fev/mar. 2012
      • News # 27 | jun. 2012
      • News # 28 | ago. 2012
      • News # 29 | set/out. 2012
      • News # 30 | nov/dez. 2012
      • News # 31 | jan. 2013
      • News # 32 | mar. 2013
      • News # 33 | abr. 2013
      • News # 34 | mai. 2013
      • News # 35 | jun. 2013
      • News # 36 | set. 2013
      •  News # 37 | out. 2013
      • News # 38 | nov/dez. 2013
    • 2014 – 2015
      • News # 39 | jan/fev. 2014
      • News # 40 | mar. 2014
      • News # 41 | abr/mai. 2014
      • News # 42 | jun/jul. 2014
      • News # 43 | set. 2014
      • News # 44 | out/nov. 2014
      • News # 45 | dez. 2014
      • News # 46 | jan. 2015
      • News # 47 | fev. 2015
      • News # 48 | abr. 2015
      • News # 49 | mai. 2015
      • News # 50 | jun. 2015
      • News # 51 | set. 2015
      • News # 52 | out. 2015
      • News # 53 | dez. 2015
    • 2016 – 2017
      • News # 54 | jan. 2016
      • News # 55 | fev. 2016
      • News # 56 | mar. 2016
      • News # 57 | abr. 2016
      • News nº 58 | may 2016
      • News # 59 | jun. 2016
      • News # 60 | jul. 2016
      • News # 61 | set. 2016
      • News # 62 | out. 2016
      • News # 63 | nov/dez. 2016
      • News # 64 | jan. 2017
      • News # 65 | fev. 2017
      • News # 66 | mar. 2017
      • News # 67 | apr. 2017
      • News # 68 | may 2017
      • News # 69 | jun. 2017
      • News # 70 | jul. 2017
      • News # 71 | set. 2017
      • News # 72 | out. 2017
      • News # 73 | nov. 2017
      • News # 74 | dez. 2017
    • 2018
      • News # 75 | jan. 2018
      • News # 76 | fev. 2018
      • News # 77 | mar. 2018
      • News # 78 | abr. 2018
      • News #79 | May 2018
  • Subscribe Newsletter
My Company
  • Home
  • Newsletters
    • 2018 – 2019
      • News nº 92 | jul. 2019
      • News nº 91 | jun. 2019
      • News nº 90 | Mai. 2019
      • News nº 89 | Abr. 2019
      • News nº 88 | Mar. 2019
      • News nº 87 | Fev. 2019
      • News nº 86 | Jan. 2019
      • News nº 85 | Dez. 2018
      • News nº 84 | Nov. 2018
      • News nº 83 | Out. 2018
      • News nº 82 | Set. 2018
      • News nº 81 | Jul. 2018
      • News nº 80 | Jun. 2018
      • News Nº 79 | Mai. 2018
      • News nº 78 | abr. 2018
      • News nº 77 | mar. 2018
      • News nº 76 | fev. 2018
      • News nº 75 | jan. 2018
    • 2016 – 2017
      • News nº 74 | dez. 2017
      • News # 73 | nov. 2017
      • News # 72 | out. 2017
      • News # 70 | set. 2017
      • News nº 70 | jul. 2017
      • News nº 69 | jun. 2017
      • News nº 68 | mai. 2017
      • News nº 67 | abr. 2017
      • News nº 66 | mar. 2017
      • News nº 65 | fev. 2017
      • News nº 64 | jan. 2017
      • News nº 63 | nov/dez. 2016
      • News nº 62 | out. 2016
      • News nº 61 | set. 2016
      • News nº 60 | jul. 2016
      • News nº 59 | jun. 2016
      • News nº 58 | mai. 2016
      • News nº 57 | abr. 2016
      • News nº 56 | mar. 2016
      • News nº 55 | fev. 2016
      • News nº 54 | jan. 2016
    • 2014 – 2015
      • News nº 53 | dez. 2015
      • News nº 52 | out. 2015
      • News nº 51 | set. 2015
      • News nº 50 | jun. 2015
      • News nº 49 | mai. 2015
      • News nº 48 | abr. 2015
      • News nº 47 | fev. 2015
      • News nº 46 | jan. 2015
      • News nº 45 | dez. 2014
      • News nº 44 | out/nov. 2014
      • News nº 43 | set. 2014
      • News nº 42 | jun/jul. 2014
      • News nº 41 | abr/mai. 2014
      • News nº 40 | mar. 2014
      • News nº 39 | jan/fev. 2014
    • 2012 – 2013
      • News nº 38 | nov/dez. 2013
      • News nº 37 | out. 2013
      • News nº 36 | set. 2013
      • News nº 35 | jun. 2013
      • News nº 34 | mai. 2013
      • News nº 33 | abr. 2013
      • News nº 32 | mar. 2013
      • News nº 31 | jan. 2013
      • News nº 30 | nov/dez. 2012
      • News nº 29 | set/out. 2012
      • News nº 28 | ago. 2012
      • News nº 27 | jun. 2012
      • News nº 26 | fev/mar. 2012
      • News nº 25 | jan. 2012
    • 2010 – 2011
      • News nº 24 | nov/dez. 2011
      • News nº 23 | set/out. 2011
      • News nº 22 | jul/ago. 2011
      • News nº 21 | mai/jun. 2011
      • News nº 20 | mar/abr. 2011
      • News nº 19 | jan/fev. 2011
      • News nº 18 | dez. 2010
      • News nº 17 | out/nov. 2010
      • News nº 16 | ago/set. 2010
      • News nº 15 | jun/jul. 2010
      • News nº 14 | mai. 2010
      • News nº 13 | abr. 2010
      • News nº 12 | mar. 2010
      • News nº 11 | jan/fev. 2010
    • 2008 – 2009
      • News nº 10 | nov/dez. 2009
      • News nº 9 | out. 2009
      • News nº 8 | ago/set. 2009
      • News nº 7 | jul. 2009
      • News nº 6 | mai/jun. 2009
      • News nº 5 | abr. 2009
      • News nº 4 | mar. 2009
      • News nº 3 | jan/fev. 2009
      • News nº 2 | dez. 2008
      • News nº 1 | nov. 2008
  • Subscrever Newsletter
  • Contacto
Main Menu
  • Home
  • Newsletters
    • 2018 – 2019
      • News nº 92 | jul. 2019
      • News nº 91 | jun. 2019
      • News nº 90 | Mai. 2019
      • News nº 89 | Abr. 2019
      • News nº 88 | Mar. 2019
      • News nº 87 | Fev. 2019
      • News nº 86 | Jan. 2019
      • News nº 85 | Dez. 2018
      • News nº 84 | Nov. 2018
      • News nº 83 | Out. 2018
      • News nº 82 | Set. 2018
      • News nº 81 | Jul. 2018
      • News nº 80 | Jun. 2018
      • News Nº 79 | Mai. 2018
      • News nº 78 | abr. 2018
      • News nº 77 | mar. 2018
      • News nº 76 | fev. 2018
      • News nº 75 | jan. 2018
    • 2016 – 2017
      • News nº 74 | dez. 2017
      • News # 73 | nov. 2017
      • News # 72 | out. 2017
      • News # 70 | set. 2017
      • News nº 70 | jul. 2017
      • News nº 69 | jun. 2017
      • News nº 68 | mai. 2017
      • News nº 67 | abr. 2017
      • News nº 66 | mar. 2017
      • News nº 65 | fev. 2017
      • News nº 64 | jan. 2017
      • News nº 63 | nov/dez. 2016
      • News nº 62 | out. 2016
      • News nº 61 | set. 2016
      • News nº 60 | jul. 2016
      • News nº 59 | jun. 2016
      • News nº 58 | mai. 2016
      • News nº 57 | abr. 2016
      • News nº 56 | mar. 2016
      • News nº 55 | fev. 2016
      • News nº 54 | jan. 2016
    • 2014 – 2015
      • News nº 53 | dez. 2015
      • News nº 52 | out. 2015
      • News nº 51 | set. 2015
      • News nº 50 | jun. 2015
      • News nº 49 | mai. 2015
      • News nº 48 | abr. 2015
      • News nº 47 | fev. 2015
      • News nº 46 | jan. 2015
      • News nº 45 | dez. 2014
      • News nº 44 | out/nov. 2014
      • News nº 43 | set. 2014
      • News nº 42 | jun/jul. 2014
      • News nº 41 | abr/mai. 2014
      • News nº 40 | mar. 2014
      • News nº 39 | jan/fev. 2014
    • 2012 – 2013
      • News nº 38 | nov/dez. 2013
      • News nº 37 | out. 2013
      • News nº 36 | set. 2013
      • News nº 35 | jun. 2013
      • News nº 34 | mai. 2013
      • News nº 33 | abr. 2013
      • News nº 32 | mar. 2013
      • News nº 31 | jan. 2013
      • News nº 30 | nov/dez. 2012
      • News nº 29 | set/out. 2012
      • News nº 28 | ago. 2012
      • News nº 27 | jun. 2012
      • News nº 26 | fev/mar. 2012
      • News nº 25 | jan. 2012
    • 2010 – 2011
      • News nº 24 | nov/dez. 2011
      • News nº 23 | set/out. 2011
      • News nº 22 | jul/ago. 2011
      • News nº 21 | mai/jun. 2011
      • News nº 20 | mar/abr. 2011
      • News nº 19 | jan/fev. 2011
      • News nº 18 | dez. 2010
      • News nº 17 | out/nov. 2010
      • News nº 16 | ago/set. 2010
      • News nº 15 | jun/jul. 2010
      • News nº 14 | mai. 2010
      • News nº 13 | abr. 2010
      • News nº 12 | mar. 2010
      • News nº 11 | jan/fev. 2010
    • 2008 – 2009
      • News nº 10 | nov/dez. 2009
      • News nº 9 | out. 2009
      • News nº 8 | ago/set. 2009
      • News nº 7 | jul. 2009
      • News nº 6 | mai/jun. 2009
      • News nº 5 | abr. 2009
      • News nº 4 | mar. 2009
      • News nº 3 | jan/fev. 2009
      • News nº 2 | dez. 2008
      • News nº 1 | nov. 2008
  • Subscrever Newsletter
  • Contacto

The Wisdom of the Tribe – To João Lobo Antunes in memoriam

By etavares On 31 October, 2016 2016 | Moments Comments Off on The Wisdom of the Tribe – To João Lobo Antunes in memoriam No tags

João Lobo Antunes was a major figure of the Faculty of Medicine, of the University and of the Portuguese public life in recent decades. He was an example of the man of culture, of whom it can justly be said that nothing was indifferent to him, in Medicine and Science, in Art and Civic Intervention.

At a time when Academic Medicine seems to go through an identity and future crisis, not only in Portugal but also in Europe and the United States – suffice to recall the editorial in The Lancet about the need to recover this fundamental dimension of Medicine – John Lobo Antunes embodied the Homo Academicus, whose attributes are scientific culture, modernity in clinical performance, commitment to knowledge for the practice of science, objectivity, ongoing critical reflection, and respect for the values of ethics and professionalism.

As a Neurosurgeon, Director of Unit and Professor, he renewed the specialty at the institution, and his unit is now a reference in the national and international scene. He also trained a range of employees who will know how to continue his work.

Neurosurgery, with its specificities and hospital organization, is a world apart everywhere. In our institution it occupies a separate area, apart from the rest of the surgical activity, with its own Operating Room and Intensive Care areas and equipment that allow its functioning and which obviously cannot be dispersed. But it is part of the world and culture of Surgery, being an indispensable component of its core unit, which Owen Wangesteen referred to. Education in Surgery, the development of its academic dimension, incorporating intelligent and useful technological innovation and defence of an ethical and human vision, today are priorities in the necessary reflection on the Present and the Future of Surgery.

We shared common interests. In surgery, it was cerebrovascular disease and stroke prevention. From his American experience, he was slightly interested in carotid surgery, but quickly realized that in our reality, we were the vascular surgeons who had tradition, know-how and expertise. He accepted this fact naturally, encouraging our participation in the clinical meetings of his unit and in the international meetings he organized, like the European Society of Neurosurgery, which he presided, and honoured us with an invitation to a plenary lesson. In our surgical specialties, we experienced the tremendous impact of technology, which changed the image of the disease and therapeutic intervention. João did not escape the fascination of reflecting on the hand, which identifies us and gives a name to our healing art – Surgery is the art of healing with our hands – and he continued this concern, a legacy from João Cid dos Santos, who liked that his photographs included his hand! – But he agreed with our Master who, evoking Leonardo da Vinci, argued that surgery as art was a mental affaire, and that knowledge, decisiveness, courage, and humanity are prerequisites for excellence in surgery and not just the skilled hand of the craftsman.

Education in Surgery requires a deep reflection. For years I have been expressing my concern about the excessive fragmentation of the training of surgeons, about the lack of sufficient (longer) time for what I have called General Education in Surgery, before the young aspiring surgeon can choose his future path, his area of intervention. The acceleration of current time, the vicissitudes of hospital careers with the need for rapid and increasingly specialized training and even the very hospital organization, have contributed to an increasingly tapered – single dimensional (?) vision of surgical science and its excessive compartmentalization.

In his book on Hamilton Bailey – A Surgeon’s life, Adrian Marston wondered about the future of the surgeon and I quote the original text for its elegance… the new professional will be the expert and to label him/her as radiologist, surgeon, technician, will become futile …. they will be experts of a new type, servants of society, no longer guardians of tribal wisdom.

The working meetings between the two of us were relatively frequent, while I was Director of the Faculty. They were usually short, objective, without wasting time. But I remember one day when the conversation drifted to the evolution of surgery, the need to preserve Surgical Culture – the wisdom of the tribe. We shared the view, perhaps romantic, of the need for commitment to the art and science of surgery and that objective was a necessity for the survival of the surgical ethos.

The academic dimension in surgical specialties is a crucial problem for the survival of Academic Surgery, a subject that was one of his concerns, which he wrote about, sharing his American experience. It is an institutional challenge that we cannot miss!

His commitment to knowledge through the exercise of Science, the attribute of the homo academicus, has perhaps been the ultimate reason for his commitment to the implementation of the Institute of Molecular Medicine (IMM), taking advantage of legislation that favoured the emergence of Innovation and Research Centres and more dynamic and less bureaucratic governance models. The change was remarkable, represented an upgrade in our nature interrogation capacity.

For its mission, the increasingly dynamic integration with the Medical School and the Hospital is fundamental, and that was the main goal that presided over the launch of the Academic Medical Centre, a consortium of three institutions, where he supported me and of which he was also a subscriber. I believe that its development is imperative, as it promotes research and innovation, contributing to the development of medicine and our claim to be an academic institution with genuine European dimension in Science, Education and Clinical Practice. It is a milestone and a decisive step in the necessary reform in health, education and training of doctors and other health professionals’ academic institutions.

It was that medical and surgical culture which, along with his expertise as a neurosurgeon, gave him a bird’s eye stance in surgical art and technique, and, with his humanity on the doctor-patient relationship, made his memory imperishable. We have always worked in different private institutions, but that fact has never stopped the shared referencing of some patients. I transcribe this email I received from a patient (a real one, whose identification is omitted for obvious reasons) that is an eloquent testimony of what I have just said:

Dr, my best regards
It was with surprise and sorrow that I heard that Dr Lobo Antunes has died.
It was he who brought me to you, after reviewing my exams.
I was there, because the pain in my back was unbearable.
It is with sadness that I learned of his death, because he was
an extraordinary person to me, explaining what was really affecting me.
To all colleagues, family and friends, I offer my condolences.

What more can a physician aspire to than the unselfish and enduring gratitude of his patients?

We belong to a generation that lived through and took on a change challenge, and that was also great progress in our country. Could it have been better? Certainly yes, the unrest, the constant quest to do more and better are also attributes of the surgical ethos.

The reflection Reynaldo dos Santos started and others continued on the Training of Elites and their priority in a small nation, remains increasingly present, and is a categorical imperative that the Portuguese intelligence cannot ignore.

The memory of João Lobo Antunes’ work, his intelligence and his sense of duty will be an inspiration and encouragement to all of us.

 

 

FMUL, 2 November 2016

 

José Fernandes e Fernandes

Full Professor and Dean of the Surgery Group

 

 

 

 

Share

Search

Index – News # 62 | out. 2016
 Renewal
 Presentation of the Chemistry College of the ULisboa
 The Multidisciplinary Advanced Simulation Centre will open in 2017
 Opening of the Academic Year 2016-2017
 Inauguration of the first Master Degree in Hyperbaric and Underwater Medicine in Portugal
 European Researchers’ Night
 2nd Session II of the Graduate Students’ Integration Committee
 Last Lesson of Professor Daniel Sampaio – 26 October 2016
 Last Lesson of Professor Luís Mendes Graça – 19 September 2016
 New Kaleidoscope of the University of Lisbon
 Scientific publications (FMUL/HSM/IMM) – October 2016
 Educational Cooperation Agreement between FMUL and DCBM UALG
 October News
 The Wisdom of the Tribe – To João Lobo Antunes in memoriam
 In Memoriam
 A quantum leap
 Manuel de Mello Scholarship
 Basic Course in Geriatrics
 Third Edition of the Education and Medical Education Day
 15th Edition “Hospital of the Little Ones” – 21 and 25 November
 FCT informs that in the weeks 3-17 October announced the opening of the following contests for scholarships and awards:
 Cooking and Healthy Eating Day
 2nd Annual Meeting of Doctoral Students | Mind-Brain Doctoral College of ULisboa – 28 and 29 November
 Junior Doctors International Meeting | 11 to 13 november
 OBITUARY | Death of Professor António Baptista Fernandes
 Death of Professor João Lobo Antunes
My Company

100 AnosPropriedade e Edição: Faculdade de Medicina da Universidade de Lisboa NIPC: 502662875  Periodicidade: Mensal  Diretor: Prof. Doutor Fausto J. Pinto Conselho Editorial: Prof. Doutor Fausto J. Pinto, Profª. Doutora Ana Sebastião, Prof. Doutor Mamede de Carvalho, Prof. Doutor António Vaz Carneiro, Prof. Doutor Miguel Castanho, Dr. Luís Pereira  Equipa Editorial:  Ana Raquel Moreira, Cristina Bastos, Isabel Varela, Joana Sousa, Maria de Lurdes Barata, Rui Gomes, Sónia Teixeira  Colaboração:  Gabinete de Relações Públicas, Internacionais e Comunicação  Versão Inglesa: AP|PORTUGAL- Language Services  Conceção: Metatexto, Lda. e-mail: news@medicina.ulisboa.pt  Sede do Editor e Sede da Redação: Avenida Prof. Egas Moniz, 1649-028 Lisboa Estatuto Editorial Anotado na ERC 

  • Increase Font
  • Decrease Font
  • Black & White
  • Inverse Colors
  • Highlight Links
  • Regular Font
  • Reset
Real Accessability